Virtual Medical Centre

Study investigates the cost effectiveness of spinal surgery

22 January 2009
Back pain affects more than 80 percent of people and costs more than $100 billion annually in the U.S.  But is the surgery cost effective? A study by researchers at Rush University Medical Center suggests that for patients with spinal stenosis, a laminectomy, or surgical removal of some soft bone and tissue, is a reasonable value. However, for patients with spinal stenosis with associated slipped vertebrae, the benefits of spinal fusion surgery may not be enough to offset costs. The study is published in the December 16 issue of the Annals of Internal Medicine.

Rush was one of 13 sites throughout the country and the only Chicago site that followed patients in the Spine Patient Outcomes Research Trial (SPORT).
 
“This study is significant because it is the first to systematically track people’s health care expenditures and health outcomes,” said Dr. Gunnar Andersson, former chairman of the department of Orthopaedics at Rush and study investigator.  “More than 650,000 surgical procedures are performed annually for back pain in the United States with costs exceeding $20 billion.  Whether this investment provides good value is largely unknown.”

The study looked at two conditions, spinal stenosis that is treated most commonly with laminectomy, which is a procedure where orthopaedic surgeons remove the portion of the vertebral bone called the lamina and soft tissue to relieve pressure on the nerves in the spine. The second condition that was analysed is spinal stenosis with slipped vertebrae also known as spinal stenosis with degenerative spondylolisthesis, which is most commonly treated with spine fusion surgery.

More than 3,900 patients participated in the randomised, controlled trial of surgery versus non-operative treatment. 320 patients underwent laminectomy and 344 patients had spinal fusion.

Researchers used the Quality Adjusted Life Year (QALY) scale to measure benefit to patients in comparison to the direct and indirect costs of the surgical procedures over a two-year period after surgery. The researchers calculate that stenosis surgery using laminectomy cost is $77,000 per QALY gained.  In contrast, spinal fusion surgery for stenosis with slipped vertebrae cost about $115,000 per QALY gained.  In the U.S., $100,000 is the threshold at which procedures are considered to be cost effective?